Writer's Digest

Kill With Your Critique … the Good Way

Revision and editing advice to take your first draft to the next level.

As The Picture Book Whisperer and Editor for Bushel & Peck Books, I’m regularly invited to conferences to give manuscript critiques. Most recently, I participated in the Florida SCBWI (Society of Children’s Book Writers & Illustrators) Critique-a-Palooza, and from the feedback I received on my critiques, I scored like a champ. Since these involved 15-minute Zoom conversations with the authors, I already knew that—I witnessed how my written and verbal comments were difference-making.

Best of all, no one cried.

You might think that last sentence was left in for the comedic value, but here’s the truth—when I started teaching writing at the college level 20-whatever years ago, I make someone cry. Maybe even a few someones. Why? Because it’d been commonplace in my grad school writing workshops for students to get blubbery during or immediately after a professor’s critique. After all, when speaking about critiques, don’t we often use words like “destroy,”

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Writer's Digest

Writer's Digest1 min read
Writer's Digest
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF Amy Jones SENIOR EDITOR Robert Lee Brewer MANAGING EDITOR Moriah Richard EDITORS Sadie Dean Michael Woodson EDITORIAL INTERN Hannah Spicer ART DIRECTOR Wendy Dunning EDITORS-AT-LARGE Tyler Moss Jessica Strawser CONTRIBUTING EDITORS Ja
Writer's Digest2 min read
Characterizing Through Relationships
Today is her forty-fifth birthday. She finds it hard to believe. Once she’d been young and she’d thought forty-five would come slow and impossible. She’d thought forty-five would be another world. But it came fast and it’s not what she thought it wou
Writer's Digest4 min read
You Got The Offer—Should You Sign?
Congratulations! You’ve received an offer of representation from your Dream Agent. It’s the moment you’ve been waiting for. In the good ole’ days of threehour lunches and cocktails sharply at 5 p.m., many authors signed with their agents on a handsha

Related