BBC History Magazine

Did they really have to fight to the finish?

On 28 September 1916 David Lloyd George, then Britain’s minister of war, gave an interview to the American news agency United Press that became instantly famous. Asked how long the conflict in which his nation was currently embroiled would last, and how it may end, he said: “The fight must be to the finish – to a knockout.

“The inhumanity, the pitilessness of the fighting that must come before a lasting peace is possible, is not comparable with the cruelty that would be involved in stopping the war while there remains a possibility of civilisation again being menaced from the same quarter,” Lloyd George opined. “Peace now, or at any time before the final complete elimination of this menace, is unthinkable.”

In short, Lloyd George believed it was necessary for Britain to wage war until it had achieved absolute victory. And he did so for two principal reasons. First, he blamed his counterparts in the Central Powers of Germany and Austria-Hungary for the outbreak of the First World War, and for cruelties and barbarism committed during the course of the conflict. This, in itself, made the idea of negotiating utterly repulsive. Second, the enormity of human sacrifices rendered the proposal to end the war by compromise completely unattractive. Leaders on all sides were keenly aware that something positive had to come

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from BBC History Magazine

BBC History Magazine3 min read
A Cumbrian Work Of Art
Battle-weary medieval kings, eminent Victorian architects and some of Britain's greatest artistic treasures have all passed below Muncaster Castle's imposing walls during its long and distinguished lifetime. Built from distinctive red stone, and boas
BBC History Magazine2 min read
Solution To Our March 2024 Crossword
Across 1 Regicide 5 Sousa 9 Bruce 10 Suetonius 11 Rosa Parks 12 Munda 13 Sparta 15 Paul Nash 17 Marianne 19 Rocket 22 Gupta 24 Clothilde 26 Allotment 27 Aisne 28 Anson 29 Matthias Down 1 Roberts 2 Gauls 3 Cleopatra 4/5 Desert Storm 6 Union Jack 7 Ans
BBC History Magazine2 min read
Alfred Russel Wallace 1823-1913
Alfred Russel Wallace was a British naturalist, explorer, geographer, anthropologist and biologist. Besides independently conceiving the idea of evolution through natural selection at around the same time as Charles Darwin, he explored the Amazon riv

Related Books & Audiobooks