BBC History Magazine

“The idea that political projects such as nation-making can ever be totally successful is a misconception”

Matt Elton: Your new book covers what you describe as “the South Asian 20th century”. What do you mean by that term?

Joya Chatterji: I focus on the area ruled by the former British Raj, formally or informally. I think of there being a kind of united south Asia in which glimmers of the British empire (and the social structures that predated it) could still be made out throughout the latter half of the 20th century - long after the British themselves had left.

I’m also keen to push back against the idea that the history of India, Pakistan or Bangladesh can be understood independently of that of the others. They’re too intertwined. It just wasn’t the case that they were all somehow born entirely anew after partition in 1947 or 1971. In trying to understand the processes by which they were fashioned, and the effort that was put into trying to create new nations and new citizens so apparently different from each other, we can also see much about the parallels and the commonalities.

One of the landmark political moments in this history is the 1947 Partition of India. Do you think that the events and repercussions of that episode are misunderstood outside south Asia?

The level of ignorance is quite astonishing - even in Britain, where you might expect a greater awareness because of its close involvement in the event, not least by British prime minister Clement Attlee and [last Viceroy of India] Lord Louis Mountbatten. Of course, that’s partly because many partition migrants haven’t told their stories, so we’re missing out on a fully layered version of what happened although this

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from BBC History Magazine

BBC History Magazine10 min read
Banished. Exiled. Died… Widowed. Berated. Survived.
THEY ARE INVISIBLE BUT INDISPENSABLE. Unremarked, yet always there. Tudor ladies-in-waiting have long been depicted as mere ‘scenery’ in books, plays and films about the 16th century, a backdrop of pretty faces. This is accurate – to a point. A queen
BBC History Magazine2 min read
Dramatic Tales
In November 1682, bodies pressed into Westminster Hall for the trial of Lord Grey, who stood accused of seducing his teenage sister-in-law Henrietta Berkeley into “whoredom and adultery”. Those hoping for theatrics were not disappointed: she arrived,
BBC History Magazine6 min read
Anniversaries
But Nan Winton faces prejudice When Nancy Wigginton – better known by her professional name, Nan Winton – appeared on the nation’s television sets on 20 June 1960, she became the first woman to present the national news on the BBC. The corporation’s

Related Books & Audiobooks