The Critic Magazine

Plenty of atmosphere — but only one ha-ha

THIS MONTH’S SELECTIONS give the lie to the common complaint that fiction today from mainstream publishers is generic, unadventurous and formulaic. There is a lot of that stuff about, true, and it pays the bills — but they aren’t the only stories. Indeed, what’s most interesting is that in our increasingly fragmented media age, the stuff at the fringes stands as much of a chance of making it big as the fiction-by-numbers does. Is it always good? Well, one step at a time.

Take Max Porter. The former bookseller and editor in 2015 made a huge success of the most unexpected material: inspired by Emily Dickinson, Ted Hughes and his own idiosyncratic imagination, his debut Grief is the Thing with Feathers won all the awards going and continues to sell handsomely. His second novel Lanny (2019) blended English rural mythology with a missing-child page-turner.

His new novel (singer PJ Harvey says she was “changed” by it, but we’s vulnerable hero with ’s polyphonic style and brevity. But where was soft, is hard — a 16-year-old boy, troubled or troublesome depending on viewpoint, and he’s one of the kids at Last Chance, a special school currently facing closure.

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Critic Magazine

The Critic Magazine4 min read
Cricket’s Triple Threat
JUST BEFORE TEA ON THE SECOND day of the Lord’s Test match in 1990, GRAHAM GOOCH nudged a single that took his score to 299. The England captain then removed his white helmet and placed it in front of the stumps before sloping off for a cuppa. The im
The Critic Magazine4 min read
Michael Prodger on Art
SOMETIME AROUND 1909, THE Romanian sculptor Constantin Brâncuși was approached by “a lady from Paris, a princess” with a commission to carve her portrait. Brâncuși, a leading Modernist, had a “miserably low opinion” of traditional sculpture, even des
The Critic Magazine4 min read
Adam LeBor on Television
I’M BECOMING AN EVER MORE loyal devotee of Walter Presents, the sub-channel on Channel Four devoted to European crime and thrillers. Walter curates a kaleidoscopic showcase of topical dramas in vivid settings. In the first season of Arctic Circle, Ni

Related Books & Audiobooks