New Zealand Listener

Change for the better

I spent many hours sitting alongside my beautiful wife in ward 10 of National Women’s Hospital as her life gradually leaked away from the ravages of cervical cancer. She was under the care of Associate Professor Herbert Green, as were 15 other women in the ward, all coping with cervical cancer.

Green’s method of treating cervical cancer was brought into focus by the Cartwright Inquiry and was found wanting. His theory of non-intervention and other treatments condemned many women, including my wife, to a horrible, painful death.

Green’s treatment was based upon whim and misbelief as he pursued unfounded theories for 20 years. These treatments lacked scientific validity and lacked ethical considerations.

Dr Helen Overton’s book Demonising A Good Doctor, featured in “The unfortunate consequence” (April 22), says the inquiry “profoundly changed the way the health system is managed”.

Yes, it did change the health system. It changed it to such an extent that now, cervical cancer is almost conquered. No more is there a ward full of women waiting to die. No more do we see a senior medical professional sweeping through the ward with a retinue of white-coated juniors in his wake,

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from New Zealand Listener

New Zealand Listener3 min read
Upwardly Mobile
Slowly but surely, the transport mode shift we’ve been told is required to cut carbon emissions is happening around the country. In some places, it’s also having unintended consequences. In my part of Wellington, Oriental Bay, a new bike lane at the
New Zealand Listener3 min read
Uncovering Our Past
There’s a Māori whakataukī (proverb) that says, “Kia whakatōmuri te haere whakamua. / I walk backwards into the future with my eyes fixed on the past.” The loop of past, present and future speaks to New Zealand Wars: Stories of Tauranga Moana, the la
New Zealand Listener7 min read
Fast Track To Destruction
What exactly is meant by red and green tape (Politics, April 20)? A favourite term used by our prime minister in his commentary on our democratic processes. Red tape in the past referred to the binding around administrative files. Perhaps the referen

Related Books & Audiobooks