Writer's Digest

How to Deal With a Nightmare Edit

There’s an adage that a camel is a horse designed by a committee. And, well, you might say that a magazine article is literature designed by a committee. Usually, the collaboration between editor and writer works out just fine. But every so often, you wind up with the camel.

After 15 years of freelancing and working smoothly with dozens and dozens of editors, it was finally the day of the dromedary. I pitched an article to a great outlet I wanted to write for… and my luck ran out.

Now, I should add up front that having worked as both a writer and magazine editor, I love the editorial process and the value of a solid collaboration. If anything, I let too much slide. I hate conflict and am largely a wimp. I’m overly polite. I’ve been mistaken for being a kindly Canadian.

But as a career writer, your byline is all you’ve got—and so you better defend its honor when you’re chosen for trial by editorial combat.

What do you do when an editor takes your piece and nukes it, rewrites chunks of it in a

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Writer's Digest

Writer's Digest5 min read
“I Give Me All My Yeses.”
Bea Northwick wrote her first novel around 2015. Her children were getting older, and she had more time on her hands, so she returned to an early love—books. With that first novel, Northwick, who has her master’s degree in library science, participat
Writer's Digest5 min read
Parents as Publishers
The world of children’s publishing is tough. Publishing houses are consolidating, print sales are struggling, and profit margins are narrow. Because of this economic reality, many publishers lean heavily into “sure things”—like celebrity books, seque
Writer's Digest6 min read
Septet as Memoir
An old poet friend commemorated his 60th birthday by publishing a chapbook of sestets. I liked the idea, so in 2018, when I started my 70th year on this planet, I decided to write a collection of septets. I took my friend’s idea a couple steps furthe

Related Books & Audiobooks