The Writer

THE FATAL FLAW

AT some point in writing your novel, you might imagine a minefield as you face one problem after another. But clearly, some problems are greater than others. Some could be so-called “fatal flaws.”

Examples?

What if you realize halfway through that your protagonist seems downright dull? What if your plot is very shaky? Is there a plot? What if the voice of the novel is exceedingly flat?

These are major, not minor, problems.

What then? Are such problems insurmountable?

What do seasoned novelists say? We asked six well-published novelists for their take on this issue: What are some examples of fatal flaws? What can you do to fix them? Are some unfixable?

SOME FLAWS ARE SO SERIOUS THAT they mar the integrity of your novel. They constitute a fatal flaw, and they come in many forms.

A novel is fatally flawed, says Carleton Eastlake, novelist and television writer-producer, if it doesn’t give the reader a “vicarious emotional experience.” For him, good novels “let us fall in love, solve a murder, or survive on Mars – from the safety of a cozy bed at midnight.”

Fatal flaws, he says, “impede the willing suspension of disbelief and kick us out of emotionally experiencing the novel.” Two flaws that can block a reader’s emotional experience are awful language and flat characters.

“IF THE NOVEL ENDS WITH

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Writer

The Writer1 min read
Month Ahead
Herman Melville was born on this day in 1819. He began writing Moby Dick in 1850 and finished 18 months later. Writer and activist James Baldwin was born on this day in 1924. Cape Cod Writers Center Conference begins. capecodwriterscenter.org Treat y
The Writer3 min read
Art Of The Interview
INTERVIEWING IS A HIGH ART. Whether a series of questions conducted for a primetime television show, the probing of characters by a fiction writer or the one-chance question shouted at a public figure, the results can make or break the final product.
The Writer8 min read
Comfortable With The Uncomfortable
Susanna Moore belongs to a small class of writers whose work performs the paradoxical miracle of giving solace by offering none. For all their sensuous engagement with the Hawaiian landscape of her childhood (which led to the myopic critical judgment

Related Books & Audiobooks