New Zealand Listener

In defence of men

The fragile dynamic between the sexes has always been somewhat fraught. Thirty years ago, American relationship counsellor John Gray seemed to hit both a nerve and a gold mine when he managed to shift more than 15 million copies of his bestseller, Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus.

Since then, things appear to have got even more complicated, with incels (involuntary celibates), #MeToo, easyaccess pornography and revenge politics prompting some to question the gravitational forces driving the entire solar system. What on earth is going on? English writer and philosopher Nina Power thinks she knows. Chasms have opened up in society because the battle between the sexes has become a zero-sum game, she maintains.

In What Do Men Want? Masculinity and its discontents, Power, 43, attempts to paper over the cracks and engineer bridges over the canyons. The book is practically guaranteed to make everyone uncomfortable.

Parts will enrage feminists who want men to take responsibility for what they see as the many and varied crimes of the male specimens of our species. Other sections will frustrate men who see themselves as individuals rather than members of a tribe that collectively commits most human violence.

Perhaps unity in discomfort is what is required to make all of us look up from our phones, stop tweeting #NotAllMen (whether in seriousness or sarcasm), and shuffle towards the middle ground. Or maybe Power will just enrage some people even more.

Her previous book, takes aim at consumerism and argues that the relentless drive towards accumulating more stuff has imprisoned women, rather than freeing them.

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from New Zealand Listener

New Zealand Listener2 min read
Wild At Heart
Irish author and critic Sinéad Gleeson’s 2019 collection of essays, Constellations, was an unflinching and generous look at trauma, illness, pain, faith, pregnancy and motherhood, with thunderbolt flashes of art criticism and political commentary. He
New Zealand Listener3 min read
Tv Films
Warmed-over beefcake Three, 8.30pm In the rambling second of Channing Tatum’s three malestripper flicks, the first one’s MVP Matthew McConaughey is missing. It’s also a pointless, plot-free film that the previous movie somehow avoided becoming. (2015
New Zealand Listener1 min read
Charm Comes Before A Fall
THE FALL GUY Directed by David Leitch The Fall Guy is quite silly, largely incoherent and not really worthy of the talents of its stars, Emily Blunt and Ryan Gosling. But with Aaron Taylor-Johnson –the rumoured James Bond-to-be –in support, the movi

Related Books & Audiobooks