Cook's Illustrated

The Wide World of Vanilla

Over the years the word “vanilla” has become synonymous with “plain” or “boring,” which is unfair; vanilla is bursting with complex flavors. It can taste smoky, spicy, floral, and even fruity given the species, where it’s grown, and how the vanilla beans are cured.

There are two common species of vanilla: Vanilla planifolia and Vanilla tahitensis. V. planifolia is more widely grown and is used in most commercial applications. V. tahitensis is less widely grown, and its flavor is more fruity and floral.

Vanilla flavor varies from region to region as well. According to Tim McCollum, founder and CEO of the vanilla and chocolate purveyor Beyond Good, Madagascar vanilla () is full-bodied, rich, and creamy. Mexican vanilla (, on the other hand, is “a bit warmer and spicier” than Madagascar, and Tahitian vanilla ()) is “a bit

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Cook's Illustrated

Cook's Illustrated6 min read
It’s Always Time for Arroz con Pollo
“I can close my eyes and transport myself [to] when I was little. A beautiful life growing up in Peru,” Claudia Berroa mused as she recalled the “big, delicious food” of her childhood in Lima. During a video call, Berroa, who is the ninth of 10 child
Cook's Illustrated4 min read
No-Commitment Refrigerator Preserves
Refrigerator jams and jellies are gateway preserves: quick, easy, attractive ways to bottle up peak-season produce at its best. The formulas are basic (fruit, sugar, lemon juice); the batches are typically small, so there’s no need to invest in bushe
Cook's Illustrated6 min read
The Soul of Japanese Cooking
As steam began to rise from my pot, I plucked the glistening strands of kombu from the hot water and set them aside. I pulled the pot from the heat, added a handful of katsuobushi to the water, and watched the translucent fish flakes slowly sink bene

Related