Poets & Writers

A Former Pollyanna Learns the Value of Critical Feedback

I REALLY appreciate your positivity,” said my friend Bonnie, after a few meetings of my very first writers group more than twenty-five years ago. “But I hope you’re not holding back. Sandra and I welcome constructive criticism.”

To be invited to join such an exclusive group—just three members, who gathered in Bonnie’s sitting room in her charming Victorian home every other week—was an honor. I met both women at a writers conference, and we bonded over a love of Southern writers such as Eudora Welty and Carson McCullers. However, both Bonnie and Sandra taught college-level English, and frankly these grammar doyennes intimidated me. When they shared their work I tended

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Poets & Writers

Poets & Writers3 min read
Reactions
Feedback from readers “Earth: Ground Yourself in Purpose” (January/February 2024) by Laura Spence-Ash caught my attention and my heart. I related most especially to her recounting of feedback she received in a workshop that nearly derailed her writin
Poets & Writers1 min read
Connecting New Yorkers With Writers
Every year since 1970, Poets & Writers has paid writers to participate in readings and teach creative writing workshops in New York State. Last year we distributed more than $240,000 to 557 writers participating in 1,148 readings or writing workshops
Poets & Writers4 min read
Prize Judged by Incarcerated Readers
Reginald Dwayne Betts didn’t consider himself a reader until he was sent to solitary confinement for the first time. Betts, then a teenager serving an eight-year prison sentence for carjacking, was surprised by what he saw: a world centered in many w

Related