US, China not turning inward for good, says Singapore minister, urging superpowers to 'win the world over' with leadership
Singapore believes neither the United States nor China is turning inward for good, as both recognise their dependence on the rest of the world for talent, resources and markets, one of the city state's next generation leaders said on Tuesday.
With the two superpowers competing within a single global system, success would be determined by who could manage domestic challenges and exercise global leadership "through the power of their example rather than the example of their power", Minister of Education Chan Chun Sing said.
"Whoever can create more and better opportunities for the world, whoever can provide leadership for a more connected world, whoever acts in enlightened self-interest to benefit the world rather than narrow self-interest to benefit only itself will succeed through the power of their example," he said.
Do you have questions about the biggest topics and trends from around the world? Get the answers with SCMP Knowledge, our new platform of curated content with explainers, FAQs, analyses and infographics brought to you by our award-winning team.
Minister of Education Chan Chun Sing (L) speaks at an IISS event on November 9, 2021. Photo: Facebook alt=Minister of Education Chan Chun Sing (L) speaks at an IISS event on November 9, 2021. Photo: Facebook
Chan is a member of Singapore's so-called fourth generation, or 4G, group of young leaders and is among the favourites to become the city state's next prime minister.
He said global leadership was needed now more than ever to lift the world out of the pandemic, to rebuild disrupted supply chains, and to tackle climate change.
"There is tremendous opportunity for both the US and China to focus on these global challenges and exercise their respective leadership to win the world over."
Chan, who was speaking at a lecture in Singapore organised by the International Institute for Strategic Studies think tank, said the rest of the world - including small states like Singapore - should not be bystanders in the era of great power rivalry.
Rather, they must recognise their responsibility and agency to play a constructive role and work towards an outcome in which the world remains inclusive, open and interconnected.
For a start, countries should avoid a zero-sum mentality, he said, calling it a "false dichotomy that one side must lose for the other side to win".
"We can send a clear message that we will act on principle and do not wish to be corralled into taking sides," he said. "Taking sides regardless of issues and context breeds irrelevance, and if one is irrelevant, it will almost certainly require taking sides."
Chan's comments came amid clashes between the world's two largest economies over a range of issues, even as the White House seeks to arrange a meeting between US President Joe Biden and Chinese President Xi Jinping by the end of the year.
Xi's decision against attending the G20 and the COP26 meetings in person has fuelled speculation that China is turning inward on the back of domestic challenges such as rising energy shortages and Covid-19 cases, and poor relations with the US and its Western allies.
Yet America's commitment to its allies has also been questioned since its chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan. In Asia, Washington lost economic clout after former leader Donald Trump pulled out of a trade pact that has since come to be known as the Comprehensive and Progress Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP). Britain, mainland China and Taiwan are looking to be part of the deal.
National University of Singapore law school dean Simon Chesterman referred to China's "political isolation" and "Trumpism" in the US when he asked Chan if the world had arrived at a G-zero model, with no global leader.
Chan said it was important not to "over characterise some of the short-term actions that we see" as there would always be forces wanting to connect more with the world and those that wanted to erect more barriers to protect locals.
The US had substantial economic interests in Asia and Chinese firms strived to be global enterprises, he said, and Singapore's position was that it sought to constantly value-add its relationships with both and be a relevant partner.
Asked about how Singapore could remain relevant in a changing world riven with faultlines and contests, he said the city state, as a small country, would need to "try harder", and it needed to have good ideas and ride on its advantages.
Singapore is viewed as an honest broker, according to Chan Chun Sing. Photo: AFP alt=Singapore is viewed as an honest broker, according to Chan Chun Sing. Photo: AFP
He also urged countries to come together to establish new norms for the digital world, Countries could also create new and sustainable solutions for a greener world, and work on recovering from Covid-19.
Singapore was often viewed as a "honest broker", and its credibility stemmed from not taking sides in the great power competition. It tried to bridge differences between parties that had diverse interests and would engage with all the stakeholders, including China, he said.
This was one way the city state contributed to the world. "This is not a function of the size of a country. It is a function of our reputation and the consistency with which we approach an issue," he added.
Asked about how Singaporeans should view tensions in the Taiwan Strait, Chan, a former army chief, said he did not believe Beijing would use force to retake the self-ruled island, unless it is forced to.
Singapore, Chan said, was in no position to mediate but could help facilitate meetings, such as the historic 2015 meeting between Xi and former Taiwanese leader Ma Ying-jeou.
"To the extent that we can be helpful in helping various parties understand each other's perspectives and bottom lines, I think we will do that."
This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (SCMP).
Copyright (c) 2021. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.
