Everand Logo

Welcome to Everand!

  • The Marshall Project

    The People vs. Cy Vance

    Think the Manhattan DA goes easy on the rich? Take a look at how he prosecutes the poor.
    by Tom Robbins Apr 30, 2018 9 minutes

    To hear the media tell it, Manhattan district attorney Cyrus Vance Jr. is soft on white-collar crime. First came the news that an attorney for Ivanka Trump and Donald Trump Jr. had arranged a fund-raiser for Vance after he refused to prosecute them for fraud. Then there was Vance’s decision not to file sexual-assault charges against Harvey Weinstein, even though police had caught the Hollywood mogul on tape confessing to the crime. Last month, spurred by a story in New York, Gov. Andrew Cuomo ordered the state attorney general to investigate Vance’s handling of the case. The incidents have cost the DA: During his uncontested election for a third term in November, 10 percent of voters were so fed up with him that they went to the trouble of writing in someone whose name wasn’t Cy Vance.

    But all the attention on Vance’s treatment of the rich and powerful has obscured a more surprising aspect of his record: The DA, who styles himself a progressive reformer, is actually far more punitive toward poor and minority defendants than his counterparts in other boroughs. According to a report issued last year by a special commission on Rikers Island, Vance’s office was responsible for almost 38 percent of the city’s jail population in 2016, even though it handled just 29 percent of all criminal cases in New York. “No other borough comes close,” the report concluded. Brooklyn — despite having a million more residents than Manhattan — accounted for only 22 percent of those behind bars.

    Vance’s selectively tough approach to

    You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

    More from The Marshall Project

    The Marshall Project8 min readPolitics
    No-Show Prison Workers Cost Mississippi Taxpayers Millions
    When Darrell Adams showed up for an overnight shift at the Marshall County Correctional Facility in rural Mississippi, he was one of six officers guarding about 1,000 prisoners. Adams said he thought that was normal; only half-a-dozen guards had been
    The Marshall Project4 min readCrime & Violence
    I Wasn’t a Superpredator. I Was a Kid Who Made a Terrible Decision.
    At age 14, Derrick Hardaway took part in the murder of an 11-year-old. The media used the crime to build the myth of the superpredator—and stuck him with a label he struggles to shed.
    The Marshall Project6 min readPsychology
    Prison Is Even Worse When You Have a Disability Like Autism
    State officials often fail to identify prisoners with developmental disorders, a group that faces overwhelming challenges behind bars, from bright lights to noises to social dynamics.

    Related Books & Audiobooks