About this ebook
Someone is targeting the members of the city’s supernatural underclass—those who don’t possess enough power to become full-fledged wizards. Some have vanished. Others appear to be victims of suicide. But now the culprit has left a calling card at one of the crime scenes—a message for Harry Dresden.
Harry sets out to find the apparent serial killer, but his investigation turns up evidence pointing to the one suspect he cannot possibly believe guilty: his half-brother, Thomas. To clear his brother’s name, Harry rushes into a supernatural power struggle that renders him outnumbered, outclassed, and dangerously susceptible to temptation.
And Harry knows that if he screws this one up, people will die—and one of them will be his brother...
Jim Butcher
Jim Butcher is the author of the Dresden Files, the Codex Alera and the Cinder Spires series. His résumé includes a laundry list of skills which were useful a couple of centuries ago, and he plays guitar quite badly. An avid gamer, Jim plays tabletop games in varying systems, a variety of video games and LARPs whenever he can make time for it. He currently resides mostly inside his own head, but his head can generally be found in his home town of Independence, Missouri.
Other titles in White Night Series (20)
Fool Moon Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Storm Front Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Summer Knight Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Grave Peril Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Death Masks Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5White Night Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Dead Beat Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Blood Rites Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsSmall Favor Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Proven Guilty Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Cold Days Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Ghost Story Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsTurn Coat Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Peace Talks Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Changes Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Skin Game Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Battle Ground Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Brief Cases Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Side Jobs Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Dresden Files Collection 13-15 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Read more from Jim Butcher
Urban Enemies Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Blood Lite: An Anthology of Humorous Horror Stories Presented by the Horror Writers Association Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Marvel Classic Novels - Spider-Man: The Darkest Hours Omnibus Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Related to White Night
Titles in the series (20)
Fool Moon Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Storm Front Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Summer Knight Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Grave Peril Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Death Masks Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5White Night Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Dead Beat Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Blood Rites Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsSmall Favor Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Proven Guilty Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Cold Days Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Ghost Story Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsTurn Coat Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Peace Talks Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Changes Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Skin Game Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Battle Ground Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Brief Cases Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Side Jobs Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Dresden Files Collection 13-15 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Related ebooks
Blood of Innocents Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsWhen the Goddess Wakes: Book 3 of the Ring-Sworn Trilogy Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsWhere is Anybody? Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Wind In My Heart Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Legends Saga Collection: The Legends Saga, #1 Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Death Watch Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Keepers: The Portal and the Veil Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsA Farm Boy in Oz: The Wicked Wizard of Oz, #1 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Keepers: The Harp and the Ravenvine Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Torchbearers Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Unseen: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Trapped in Transylvania: (Dracula) Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Dreams Bigger Than Heartbreak Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Arcane Detective: Oleander's Irregulars, #1 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsSpellcaster Wild Card: Spellcaster, #1 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsShira: Circle of Assassins, #1 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsWinter Tales from Cozy Vales: Cozy Vales Collection, #1 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsCold Kiss Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsGears of Wonderland Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Dragon Tax: Dragonsbane Saga, #1 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Last Shadow Gate: The Shadow Gate Chronicles Book I Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Wretched Wicked: Preternatural Affairs, #10 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Crimson Gods Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Fantasy For You
The Will of the Many Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Lord Of The Rings: One Volume Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5A Court of Thorns and Roses Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Dune Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Babel: Or the Necessity of Violence: An Arcane History of the Oxford Translators’ Revolution Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Measure: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Piranesi Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5This Is How You Lose the Time War Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Princess Bride: S. Morgenstern's Classic Tale of True Love and High Adventure Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Priory of the Orange Tree Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Slewfoot: A Tale of Bewitchery Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Tress of the Emerald Sea: Secret Projects, #1 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Fairy Tale Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Court of Wings and Ruin Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Out of Oz: The Final Volume in the Wicked Years Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Alchemist: A Graphic Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Court of Frost and Starlight Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Silmarillion Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Dark Tower I: The Gunslinger Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Assassin and the Pirate Lord: A Throne of Glass Novella Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Nettle & Bone Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Night Circus: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas: A Story Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Till We Have Faces: A Myth Retold Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Remarkably Bright Creatures: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The City of Dreaming Books Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Ocean at the End of the Lane: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Between Ink and Shadows: Between Ink and Shadows, #1 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Don Quixote: [Complete & Illustrated] Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Reviews for White Night
2,197 ratings71 reviews
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Aug 4, 2025
I really like how the series is progressing. I'm not bingeing the series, so every time I return, it's like visiting old friends. I like the world building, the supporting characters, the action, and the banter. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Aug 25, 2025
I like all of Butcher's Dresden books, I like Mystery and Fantasy. You don't have to read them sequentially and they are all entertaining. - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Dec 26, 2024
Yup, second five-star in a row. I'm enjoying the hell of this series, when honestly, I shouldn't be.
Teen apprentice? Shouldn't like it.
Half-brother? Shouldn't like it.
All the ex-lovers and potential lovers? Shouldn't like it.
And yet, not only does Butcher make it work, he makes it fun. And the plot in this one was just as twisty as a long-time reader of Dresden would expect.
Great series. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Nov 10, 2022
White Night is the ninth book in The Dresden Files by Jim Butcher. In this week's episode... There's a supernatural serial killer loose in Chicago that is targeting weaker members of the city, ones who don't have enough power to become full-fledged wizards. Harry's investigation turns up evidence pointing to the one suspect he cannot believe is guilty: his half-brother Thomas. Harry teams up with his old flame Elaine to solve the crimes and clear his brother's name.
I'm going to sum this up with a quote:
"Get your head in the game Harry...Defeat the whole damn White Court now. Worry about taking on Hell later."
White Night is another solid entry into the series. I really should not take so long between reading books. I forgot how these books hit that one spot and then it's off to the races. Around chapter 10 the pace on this one picks up and doesn't let go. It's obvious that Thomas is being set up but it's quite a mystery for Harry and team to solve that takes some interesting turns. The plot on this moves several story threads that have been building throughout the series along nicely.
I'm highly impressed with how complex and nuanced the characters are becoming. Dear lord Molly needs to grow up. I definitely agree with Harry in needing to scare her straight before she gets them both killed. Murphy noticing Harry's "unexplained" anger issues that are the result of the gordian knot that is Lasciel is quite insightful.
And that ending! I am very curious to see how what Lash did plays out. I'm not entirely sure she's gone and it's great Harry is no longer tied to Lasciel. I'm also hoping that these events have bought Lara and the White Court's alliance for a little while and gives the White Council some breathing room in the war. The solution for Thomas's unique problem is absolutely perfect! - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Nov 11, 2021
Last chapter and author's notes at the end bumped up this book rating to 3.5 -- I liked it!
Butcher is a good writer. However, I find myself annoyed by phrasing such as "fairly pretty girls." - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Sep 16, 2021
This was another great installment in the series! I first read this book back in 2012 and I really enjoyed experiencing the audio with this re-read. Even having read this book before, there were a few times during this re-read that I had a hard time keeping up because there is just a lot going on. I think that I liked this book even more than I did the first time I read it. It was just immensely entertaining!
This is the ninth book in The Dresden Files series which is a series that really needs to be in order. Harry finds himself in the middle of another investigation in this installment. There is a killer targeting people with some magical ability and the murders often look like suicides to most investigators. As the investigation progresses, Harry finds clues leading to someone he knows cannot be responsible, his brother Thomas.
I thought that this book was really well done. I think that most readers that have it this far into the series have a bit of a soft spot for Harry. It was really great to see all of the characters that I have come to love in the series. I really liked the fact that Molly’s skills are starting to become more of a factor. Mouse was rather impressive and proved that he is definitely handy to have around. There was plenty of excitement to keep the story moving at a rather brisk pace.
James Marsters did a phenomenal job with the narration. I love the way that he is able to bring this series to life. The different voices that he uses for the various characters are very well done and consistent throughout the series. I know that his narration has added to my enjoyment of this story.
I would not hesitate to recommend this series to others. This book was jam-packed with a great mystery and wonderful characters. I cannot wait to continue with my re-read of this fabulous series! - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Aug 8, 2021
Finally, we find out about Thomas’ big secret he’s been keeping from Harry. It’s a good one; and, no. No spoilers.
But before Harry learns what’s up Thomas’ sleeve, he’s faced with a psychic serial killer who is stalking magic users with minor talent. The killer is also making it look like it’s all being done by a Warden from the White Council - a Warden whose shadowy form resembles one Harry Dresden, Wizard.
Helping out on Team Dresden are Murphy and Mouse, of course. Harry’s apprentice from the last book is on hand to play a supporting role. Warden Ramirez also steps in to lend a hand.
One character who steps back in after a lengthy absence is Jonny Marcone, crimelord and gangster boss. His reappearance seems to indicate Harry will have one more resource, or obstacle, in his world for future difficulties. Marcone’s reentry also adds another aspect to the already rich political detail in Harry’s life.
The confrontation and ensuing battle take a significant portion of the final quarter of the book, but are well-written enough to stay exciting. Before it’s all over, another “baddy” shows up - one we thought was dead and gone from a couple of books ago. He, too, may add special interest to future stories as we can’t be sure he’s really, really gone this time.
My hat’s off to Butcher for keeping this series going when so many others fizzle after three or four. Here’s to continuing entertainment from the Dresden Files. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Oct 3, 2019
Another entry in the "Dresden Files" series which I would classify as "not bad, but not stunning, either". I'm enjoying the series, but I also had no problem putting the audiobook down for a couple of days in the middle of the final confrontation. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Aug 2, 2019
Every time I pick up one of the Dresden Files books, I always get my hopes up. Let me tell you this much as well. There has yet to be a time where I am let down.
Book 9 of the series was no exception to that rule as well, although I did find at times that I forgot what the main plot of the story was in this one, especially at one point where I felt I skipped a chapter or two, but at the end, it all came to again.
Poor Harry Dresden, always getting himself into trouble, needing others to pull him out. We see more of Marcone in this book, as well as some of the other smaller characters, which is something I do like. I dislike when people are brought into a book, only in the one of the series, and never talked about again.
Women are going missing and being murdered. The Police see it as suicide, but soon Harry is able to see that it is not the case. These poor women are all being murdered! Who is it that is causing all of this to happen? It left me surprised actually. As the book continued on, I kept getting ideas in my head about what could be happening, but what really was was not something I had expected.
This was a good read, not my favourite out of the series, but it was still good. There was not enough Mouse and Mister in it for my tastes. I want a book all on Mister's escapades with Bob sometime. Even a small novel.
Reading this book made me happy, and it made me laugh out loud at the very end. Let me tell you, This book is worth reading. The whole series is worth reading. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Aug 2, 2019
Every time I pick up one of the Dresden Files books, I always get my hopes up. Let me tell you this much as well. There has yet to be a time where I am let down.
Book 9 of the series was no exception to that rule as well, although I did find at times that I forgot what the main plot of the story was in this one, especially at one point where I felt I skipped a chapter or two, but at the end, it all came to again.
Poor Harry Dresden, always getting himself into trouble, needing others to pull him out. We see more of Marcone in this book, as well as some of the other smaller characters, which is something I do like. I dislike when people are brought into a book, only in the one of the series, and never talked about again.
Women are going missing and being murdered. The Police see it as suicide, but soon Harry is able to see that it is not the case. These poor women are all being murdered! Who is it that is causing all of this to happen? It left me surprised actually. As the book continued on, I kept getting ideas in my head about what could be happening, but what really was was not something I had expected.
This was a good read, not my favourite out of the series, but it was still good. There was not enough Mouse and Mister in it for my tastes. I want a book all on Mister's escapades with Bob sometime. Even a small novel.
Reading this book made me happy, and it made me laugh out loud at the very end. Let me tell you, This book is worth reading. The whole series is worth reading. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jun 20, 2019
This book mainly deals with the White Court vampires. I'm not too big of a fan of this particular group, but the story is still entertaining enough. It seems like more and more people are starting to become aware of the Black Council, so it will be interesting to see how that develops and who is revealed to be a member. - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Dec 6, 2018
UPDATED: Second time around and I liked this one a LOT more. The final fight is pretty exciting, but it does go on a bit long.
3.75 stars. Super entertaining Dresden entry, but I felt like Butcher's writing is a notch lower than it was for the previous two books. Also, the insanely long battle at the end of this book just wore me out. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jun 15, 2018
Harry discovers that someone is preying on low level magic users and somehow gets dragged into a civil war among the vampires (because when does Harry not get dragged into "end of the world" situations??). There are some throwbacks to the past and more about the relationship between Harry and his brother, Thomas. Harry always amazes me with his resiliency and his strength. There's also a nice resolution to the fallen angel aspect. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
May 24, 2018
White Night
4 Stars
Harry’s search for a serial killer targeting female magical practitioners takes a dramatic turn when the murders are revealed to be part of a larger, more sinister plot to destroy all of wizard kind.
The world building and characterization are highly entertaining as usual, and there are updates on several characters from earlier books, including Helen Beckitt, John Marcone and Lara Raith, There are also developments for Harry’s new apprentice, Molly Carpenter, who is slowly coming to realize the responsibility that comes with power, Harry’s brother, Thomas, whose new profession is unusual yet strangely appropriate, and fellow warden, Carlos Ramirez whose wit makes him a particularly amusing addition to the cast.
Harry is still having trouble in his personal life with love interests, both old and new, playing a role and the storyline is quite complex with much intrigue and revelations surrounding the mysterious Black Council as well as unexpected betrayals and alliances amongst the White Court vampires.
All in all, White Night resolves some ongoing issues and introduces some new conflicts. It will be interesting to see where things go from here. - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Mar 12, 2017
This is my favourite of the Dresden Files series. It has everything - Harry getting beaten up (a lot), roles for Lara, Thomas and Lash, and Ramirez. Harry is having to cope with his own problems, plus try to keep his rather-too-eager apprentice under control.
This book has some of my favourite scenes out of the series - Ramirez and Lara (classic), and Harry and Thomas.
Can't think how many times I've read/listened to this - and there will be many more times. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Feb 13, 2017
Another solid Dresden Files novel. Not my absolute favorite, but I loved seeing more of Ramirez and Thomas.A bunch of witches have gone missing or have mysteriously killed themselves and Dresden and Murphey decide to investigate and put an end to whatever is terrorizing part of the magic community. Of course, it ends up going way deeper and darker than they imagined and lots of old players are re-introduced. It's fun and violent, and full of laughs. I particularily dug the end of it. Now on to the next one! Slowly, but surely I'll knock this series out! - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Jun 28, 2016
Note: I feel that Death Masks, Book 5, is where reading this series out of order starts to do you an injustice. This book does work as a stand alone to some extent, but you will get major spoilers for the previous books in the series and it also pulls in characters we have met before. So I recommend reading the previous books before you jump into this one.
Karrin Murphy has taken a vacation day and she has chosen to spend that day showing Harry a supposed suicide crime scene. She has her doubts and Harry Dresden, Chicago’s wizard PI, has his ways of accessing info that most people aren’t privy to. Now Harry finds himself drawn into a series of murders (which look like suicides on the surface) of low-level magic users. As he starts chasing down leads, he and Karrin can’t help but turn a questioning eye towards Thomas Wraith as a man matching his description was last seen with several of the victims.
Harry is now in charge, officially, of Molly’s magical training and this is the first murder investigation he takes her on. The first step is the morgue and a visit with the mortician Waldo Butters. Harry takes the time to teach Molly the basics about reading a corpse of some of it’s final memories. Molly was pretty nervous but her first foray into this little magic trick isn’t what any of them expected. Ha! It does give Harry one more piece of info on the killer but not near enough to figure out who it is.
This book brings back some old enemies and frenemies and brings in some new ones. There’s gentleman John Marcone, Chicago’s crime lord, and a personal favorite of mine. Harry and Marcone often grudgingly swap info and this time Harry will need Marcone’s muscle. Then there’s Thomas’s sister Lara Wraith. A new enemy plus an enemy Harry thought was dead bring some ghouls to the party and the festivities are well underway.
Murphy and Harry have messed with ghouls before. Pretty messy things and hard to kill when they are in a group. In this book, Harry has some flashbacks to one of his side jobs during a summer in New Mexico when he was training some of the new Wardens in combat magic. Ghouls are gruesome and Harry has it out for them. I like that we have this degenerate enemy that we can feel guilt-free in totally hating but I also like that Butcher doesn’t make them mindless.
Harry and a few other wizards have suspected for a while that there is some evil force working within the White Council but Harry has had no proof and no person to point the finger at. In this book, Harry gets a few more hints and some definite indicators that this nebulous evil force wants Harry out of the picture. This being a reread for me, it’s great to see how well Butcher lays some ground work here for some big things that come later.
Harry’s old flame Elaine returns to the storyline and provides Murphy and Harry with some help on their investigation. Now, I’ve never quite gotten around to trusting Elaine fully. But Harry does and for now that will have to be good enough for me. On one hand, I find her hard to trust because she doesn’t have an allegiance to any group and she works hard to stay under the radar. On the other hand, I think younger Harry might have done much the same if he had gotten the chance. So until Elaine proves to be a bad guy, I have to mark her down as an asset and a good guy.
Ramirez strolls back in to the plot and strikes up a flirt with Molly. Ramirez talks a bit of a game but once he’s faced with the White Court vampires, his sexual prowess is revealed in detail. Ha! Still, Ramirez stands besides Harry in the thick of it at the end of the book. It’s quite a show down. It is one of my favorite fight scenes in the series, and a lengthy one at that too. Harry’s snark is allowed to run lose and Lara takes the brunt of it at one point. Mouthwash indeed!
At the end, Harry discovers how Thomas has been keeping himself so well fed and he’s quite surprised! So was I the first time around. Molly has learned a bit about her own limits when it comes to combat magic and situations. Mouse, Harry’s dog, is more than he seems. And there’s tons more fall out from the happenings in this book but I don’t want to get spoilery. Over all, this book has a bit more serious tone to it. Harry is still a smart mouth and that brings some much needed comic relief to certain scenes, but the stakes have gone up. With that, the characters are all getting a bit more serious, pushing on each other harder, lines are drawn in the sand. All together, this is one of my more favorite books in the series.
Narration: James Marsters continues to give this series a fine performance. I greatly enjoyed his voice for Thomas especially when Thomas is putting on a fake French accent. His ghoulish voices sound just as demented, wet, slurred, and deceitful as I imagined they would. Once again, he does a very convincing seductive and charming Lara Wraith. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
May 29, 2016
it was the same old, it feels familiar which is nice to visit and it was a bit more coherent than the last couple. But still just "going through the motions". Took me a lot longer to finish - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Jan 29, 2016
Harry Harry Harry, what an extremely entertaining life you lead. Lash is still hanging around, waiting. Someone is killing witches, someone that looks familiar....and a love is back what's up with that, hmmm ? Thomas stole the show from you Harry, at the end it grabbed it and ran. I loved it Harry ! I'm off to the next adventure. : ) - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jan 21, 2016
Harry gets hauled into Whtie Court politics again as he investigates the disappearance and possible murder of small time magical practicioners.
Add to this, the return of an old girl friend and his worry that Thomas might possibly be getting back to his feeding habits, plus the renewed temptations of his fallen angel, Harry, as usual, has his work cut out for him. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jan 14, 2016
Low level magic practitioners disappear or commit suicide. Or so it's supposed to look. Murphy gets suspicious and consults with Harry. As they start digging, the prime suspect turns out to be his brother who's very hard to find. Add in Vampires and other assorted bad guys, and Harry is once again between a rock and a hard place and has to pull in help from all sorts of allies. Full of the usual wisecracks and lots of action, this entry in the series delivers as usual. And I absolutely love Mouse. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jun 18, 2015
The series is still going strong. Jim Butcher brings in many new elements and Harry Dresden and his companions get better and better. It's a fun series that keeps me excited for the next one. - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Apr 19, 2015
Since the first The Dresden Files book I have been waiting for a book that would finally, finally captivate me enough to give it the highest rating (because my ratings of the series gradually and certainly went from 2 to 4 stars), and BINGO - White Night is IT! Unputdownable and so engrossing that I could not stop reading it, this story has made me ridiculously excited to read the next book in the series.
101
The book has some of the best metaphors EVER
This was the room we'd been in when a necromancer and a gaggle of zombies had put a bullet through the head of Butters's capacity to ignore the world of the supernatural.
It is surprisingly quotable
...when writing a book review
I read the words, but there was an odd sense of blankness inside. I read them, understood them, but they somehow didn't seem relevant.
...when you just HATE that BIACH
The reflection of light from her teeth could have left scars on my retinas.
...when you need to explain your need for swearing to your mom or your boss
Hell, the whole practice of invective was developed to add extra emphasis when the mere meaning of the words alone just wasn't enough. And I was [AM] feeling plenty emphatic.
It has very important life lessons
Just because you start out as one thing, doesn't mean you can't grow into something else.
You don't leave an injured friend all alone.
It has genuinely funny, laugh-out-loud moments
Welcome, sir [...] May I take your coat and... and stick?
All in all, this instalment is darker, angrier and urges you to pray to God [or to Jim Butcher] to finally get Harry Dresden laid. *fingers crossed* - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Mar 6, 2015
Every one of these Dresden books is the same. They all blur together. I have no way to tell them apart. I've read about 6 of these books, and they really are pretty good. But, they are all in the average category. None of them stand out as really that awesome.
After reading this particular book, I was like, why do I keep reading these things? I mean, it's not like they're really that good or anything. It was okay. I mean, I wouldn't recommend it, really. Or would I? - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jan 12, 2015
White Court politics, the murdering of female practitioners of magic. Molly looks like she might be more than just a twit. Collapsing the deeps, Marcone's assistance = signing on as free lord on the accords. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Dec 11, 2014
Continues story of Dresden's struggle to prevent an all out war between vampire clans and humans. Dresden is a fully-developed character by now that garners interest no matter what situation he is in. I sense this series is heading for a jaw-dropping turn soon. - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Aug 6, 2014
*Book source ~ Library/audio
Harry Dresden, wizard and PI extraordinaire, discovers that witches in his city of Chicago are committing suicide at an alarming rate. Not just alarming, but suspicious. Digging into the matter Harry finds out the magical community is afraid him now that he’s a Grey Cloak or Warden of the White Council. If someone had only talked to him about the suspicious deaths then lives could have been saved. But digging into the matter doesn’t just involve finding who is responsible. Oh, no. That would be too simple and nothing in Harry’s life is ever simple. Harry needs to figure out the players and the end game fast before more people, himself included, die.
Guest reviewers:
A ~ my 16-yr-old daughter
T ~ my 15-yr-old son
K ~ my 13-yr-old son
This series continues to entertain, but I’m sure that’s no big surprise. The humor, as always, is a big hit and the mystery kept us guessing and involved. We learned more magic and with Harry training Molly we like how he’s becoming more focused and disciplined with his powerhouse talent. Learning about the magical community was interesting since not much has ever been mentioned about the lesser powers in Chicago. Elaine is back in town and we find out what she’s been up to and there are more machinations by the White Court.
Favorite characters are back: Thomas, Murphy, Marcone, Ramirez and, as always, Mouse. Everyone agrees the magical fight towards the end was awesome and Harry’s solutions are always so fun to read. Lasciel is also back and what she does is…unexpected. New baddies are introduced and an unexpected baddie turns up, one we thought was dead. Also, everyone agrees that Harry’s idea of setting up a network for the magical community is a good idea. He doesn’t like being seen as a boogeyman for the paranormal community simply because he has to be a Warden.
Favorite quotes:
“Bring it, Darth Bathrobe!”
“She gave me a hard look. ‘No one likes a wiseass, Harry.’
“Are you kidding? As long as the wiseass is talking to someone else, people love ‘em.”
“There was a sound like a human yawn, and then the skull turned slightly toward me and asked, ‘What’s up, boss?’
‘Evil’s afoot.’
‘Well, sure’, Bob said, ‘because it refuses to learn the metric system. Otherwise it would be up to a meter by now.’” - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Apr 27, 2014
When his brother seems a possible suspect in a series of murders, Harry Dresden teams up with his apprentice Molly, Sergeant Murphy, gangster Johnnie Marcone, and Elaine Mallory to clear Thomas of all suspicions, only to be dragged into the political mayhem of the various vampire Courts. Another entertaining installment in the series with the same great characters. If you like the style of the series, this won't disappoint. The plot is tight and there are a few tense and a few hilarious moments that'll keep you turning the pages. Mouse is still my favorite character, no change there. - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Nov 20, 2013
As always, very entertaining if not totally original. I always appreciated the dark overtones associated with Harry Dresden, which sets these series aside from other somewhat similar novels. I enjoyed this book even more than previous ones from Harry Dresden files somehow. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Sep 23, 2013
Harry never fails to provide entertainment, and this far into the series it's "comfort food". Or comfort reading.
Nice to see more of old frenemies, sad about the one who may be lost, my favourite of recent additions. Thoe-mass is delightful as always, and the hints of higher destiny (ok, not hints, it was stated outright) keep me looking forward.
On to the next then.
Book preview
White Night - Jim Butcher
Chapter
One
Many things are not as they seem: The worst things in life never are.
I pulled my battle-scarred, multicolored old Volkswagen Beetle up in front of a run-down Chicago apartment building, not five blocks from my own rented basement apartment. Usually, by the time the cops call me, things are pretty frantic; there’s at least one corpse, several cars, a lot of flashing blue lights, yellow-and-black tape, and members of the press—or at least the promise of the imminent arrival of same.
This crime scene was completely quiet. I saw no marked police cars, and only one ambulance, parked, its lights off. A young mother went by, one child in a stroller, the other toddling along holding Mommy’s hand. An elderly man walked a Labrador retriever past my car. No one was standing around and gawking or otherwise doing anything at all out of the ordinary.
Odd.
A creepy shiver danced over the nape of my neck, even though it was the middle of a sunny May afternoon. Normally, I didn’t start getting wigged out until I’d seen at least one nightmarish thing doing something graphic and murderous.
I put it down to the paranoia of advancing age. It isn’t like I’m all that old or anything, especially for a wizard, but age is always advancing and I’m fairly sure it’s up to no good.
I parked the Blue Beetle and headed into the apartment building. I went up several flights of stairs that needed their old tile replaced, or at least scrubbed and shined. I left them to find a hallway carpeted in a low, grey-blue pile that had been crushed down to shiny smoothness in the middle. The apartment doors were battered, old, but made of thick oak. I found Murphy waiting for me.
At five feet and small change, a hundred and not much, she didn’t exactly look like a tough Chicago cop who could face down monsters and maniacs with equal nerve. Chicks like that aren’t supposed to be blond or have a cute nose. Sometimes I think Murphy became that tough cop she didn’t look like purely for the sake of contrariness—no amount of sparkling blue eyes or seeming harmlessness could hide the steel in her nature. She gave me her we’re-at-work nod, and a terse greeting. Dresden.
Lieutenant Murphy,
I drawled, with an elaborate bow and flourish of one hand, deliberately at odds with her brusque demeanor. I wasn’t doing it out of pure contrariness. I’m not like that. I am dazzled by your presence once more.
I expected a snort of derision. Instead, she gave me a polite, brittle little smile and corrected me in a gentle tone: Sergeant Murphy.
Open mouth, insert foot. Way to go, Harry. The opening credits aren’t done rolling on this case, and you’ve already reminded Murphy of what it cost her to be your friend and ally.
Murphy had been a detective lieutenant, and in charge of Special Investigations. SI was Chicago PD’s answer to problems that didn’t fall within the boundaries of normal.
If a vampire slaughtered a transient, if a ghoul killed a graveyard watchman, or if a faerie cursed someone’s hair to start growing in instead of out, someone had to examine it. Someone had to look into it and reassure the government and the citizenry that everything was normal. It was a thankless job, but SI handled it through sheer guts and tenacity and sneakiness and by occasionally calling in Wizard Harry Dresden to give them a hand.
Her bosses got real upset about her abandoning her duties in a time of crisis, while she helped me on a case. She’d already been exiled to professional Siberia, by being put in charge of SI. By taking away the rank and status she had worked her ass off to earn, they had humiliated her, and dealt a dreadful blow to her pride and her sense of self-worth.
Sergeant,
I said, sighing. Sorry, Murph. I forgot.
She shrugged a shoulder. Don’t worry about it. I forget sometimes, too. When I answer the phone at work, mostly.
Still. I should be less stupid.
We all think that, Harry,
Murphy said, and thumped me lightly on the biceps with one fist. But no one blames you.
That’s real big of you, Mini Mouse,
I replied.
She snorted and rang for the elevator. On the way up, I asked her, It’s a lot quieter than most crime scenes, isn’t it?
She grimaced. It isn’t one.
It isn’t?
Not exactly,
she said. She glanced up at me. Not officially.
Ah,
I said. I guess I’m not actually consulting.
Not officially,
she said. They cut Stallings’s budget pretty hard. He can keep the equipment functional and the paychecks steady, barely, but . . .
I arched a brow.
I need your opinion,
she said.
About what?
She shook her head. I don’t want to prejudice you. Just look and tell me what you see.
I can do that,
I said.
I’ll pay you myself.
Murph, you don’t need to—
She gave me a very hard look.
Sergeant Murphy’s wounded pride wouldn’t allow her to take charity. I lifted my hands in mock surrender, relenting. Whatever you say, boss.
Damn right.
She took me to an apartment on the seventh floor. There were a couple of doors in the hall standing slightly open, and I caught furtive looks from their residents from the corner of my eye as we walked past. At the far end of the hall stood a pair of guys who looked like medtechs—bored, grouchy medtechs. One of them was smoking, the other leaning against a wall with his arms crossed and his cap’s bill down over his eyes. Murphy and the two of them ignored one another as Murphy opened the apartment door.
Murphy gestured for me to go in and planted her feet, clearly intending to wait.
I went into the apartment. It was small, worn, and shabby, but it was clean. A miniature jungle of very healthy green plants covered most of the far wall, framing the two windows. From the door, I could see a tiny television on a TV stand, an old stereo, and a futon.
The dead woman lay on the futon.
She had her hands folded over her stomach. I didn’t have the experience to tell exactly how long she’d been there, but the corpse had lost all its color and its stomach looked slightly distended, so I guessed that she died at least the day before. It was hard to guess at her age, but she couldn’t have been much more than thirty. She wore a pink terry-cloth bathrobe, a pair of glasses, and had her brown hair pulled up into a bun.
On the coffee table in front of the futon there was a prescription bottle, its top off, empty. A decanter of golden brown liquid, dusted for prints and covered by a layer of plastic, sat beside it, as did a tumbler that was empty but for a quarter inch of water still in its bottom, enough for a melted ice cube or two.
Next to the tumbler there was a handwritten note, also inside in a plastic bag, along with a gel-tip pen.
I looked at the woman. Then I went over to the futon and read the note:
I’m so tired of being afraid. There’s nothing left. Forgive me. Janine.
I shuddered.
I’d seen corpses before; don’t get me wrong. In fact, I’d seen crime scenes that looked like photos of Hell’s slaughterhouse. I’d smelled worse, too—believe you me, an eviscerated body puts off a stench of death and rot so vile that it is almost a solid object. By comparison to some of my previous cases, this one was quite peaceful. Well organized. Tidy, even.
It looked nothing like the home of a dead woman. Maybe that’s what made it feel so creepy. Except for Janine’s corpse, the apartment looked like its owners had just stepped out for a bite to eat.
I prowled around, careful not to touch anything. The bathroom and one of the bedrooms were like the living room: neat, a little sparse, not rich, but obviously well cared for. I hit the kitchen next. Dishes were soaking in now-cold water in the sink. In the fridge, chicken was marinating in some kind of sauce, its glass bowl covered with Saran.
I heard a quiet step behind me, and said, Suicides don’t usually leave a meal marinating, do they? Or dishes soaking to be cleaned? Or their glasses on?
Murphy made a noncommittal noise in her throat.
No pictures up anywhere,
I mused. No family portraits, graduation shots, pictures of everyone at Disneyland.
I added up some other things as I turned toward the second bedroom. No hair in the sink or bathroom trash can. No computers.
I opened the door to the master bedroom and closed my eyes, reaching out with my senses to get a feel of the room. I found what I expected.
She was a practitioner,
I said quietly.
Janine had set up her temple on a low wooden table against the east wall. As I drew near it, there was a sense of gentle energy, like heat coming up from a fire that had burned down to mostly ashes. The energy around the table had never been strong, and it was fading, and had been since the woman’s death. Within another sunrise, it would be completely gone.
There were a number of items on the table, carefully arranged: a bell, a thick, leather-bound book, probably a journal. There was also an old pewter chalice, very plain but free of tarnish, and a slender little mahogany wand with a crystal bound to its end with copper wire.
One thing was out of place.
An old, old knife, a slender-bladed weapon from the early Renaissance called a misericord, lay on the carpet in front of the shrine, its tip pointing at an angle toward the other side of the bedroom.
I grunted. I paced around the room to the knife. I hunkered down, thinking, then looked up the blade of the knife to its hilt. I paced back to the bedroom door and peered at the living room.
The hilt of the knife pointed at Janine’s body.
I went back to the bedroom and squinted down the knife toward its tip.
It was pointed at the far wall.
I glanced back at Murphy, now standing in the doorway.
Murphy tilted her head. What did you find?
Not sure yet. Hang on.
I walked over to the wall and held up my hand about half an inch from its surface. I closed my eyes and focused on a very faint trace of energy left there. After several moments of concentration, I lowered my hand again. There’s something there,
I said. But it’s too faint for me to make it out without using my Sight. And I’m getting sick of doing that.
What does that mean?
Murphy asked me.
It means I need something from my kit. Be right back.
I went outside and down to my car, where I kept a fisherman’s tackle box. I snagged it and went back up to the dead woman’s bedroom.
That’s new,
Murphy said.
I set the box on the floor and opened it. I’ve been teaching my apprentice thaumaturgy. We have to go out to the country sometimes, for safety’s sake.
I rummaged through the box and finally drew out a plastic test tube full of metallic grains. I just tossed things into a grocery sack for the first couple of weeks, but it was easier to put together a more permanent mobile kit.
What’s that?
Murphy asked.
Copper filings,
I said. They conduct energy. If there’s some kind of pattern here, I might be able to make it out.
Ah. You’re dusting for prints,
Murphy said.
Pretty much, yeah.
I pulled a lump of chalk out of my duster’s pocket and squatted to draw a very faint circle on the carpet. I willed it closed as I completed the circle, and felt it spring to life, an invisible screen of power that kept random energies away from me and focused my own magic. The spell was a delicate one, for me anyway, and trying to use it without a circle would have been like trying to light a match in a hurricane.
I closed my eyes, concentrating, and poured an ounce or two of copper filings into my right palm. I willed a whisper of energy down into the filings, enough to create a magical charge in them that would draw them toward the faint energy on the wall. When they were ready, I murmured, Illumina magnus." Then I broke the circle with my foot, releasing the spell, and cast the filings outward.
They glittered with little blue-white sparks, crackling audibly as they struck the wall and stayed there. The scent of ozone filled the air.
I leaned forward and blew gently over the wall, clearing any stray filings that might have clung to the wall on their own. Then I stepped back.
The copper filings had fallen into definite shapes—specifically, letters:
EXODUS 22:18.
Murphy furrowed her brow and stared at it. A Bible verse?
Yeah.
I don’t know that one,
she said. Do you?
I nodded. It’s one that stuck in my head: ‘Suffer not a witch to live.’
Chapter
Two
Murder, then,
Murphy said.
I grunted. Looks like.
And the killer wanted you to know it.
She came to stand beside me, frowning up at the wall. A cop couldn’t have found this.
Yeah,
I said. The empty apartment made a clicking noise, one of those settling-building, homey sounds that would have been familiar to the victim.
Murphy’s tone became lighter. So, what are we looking at here? Some kind of religious wacko? Salem Witch Trials aficionado? The Inquisitor reborn?
And he uses magic to leave a message?
I asked.
Wackos can be hypocrites.
She frowned. How did the message get there? Did a practitioner have to do it?
I shook my head. After they killed her, they probably just dipped their finger in the water in the chalice, used it to write on the wall. Water dried up, but a residue of energy remained.
She frowned. From water?
Blessed water from the cup on her shrine,
I said. Think of it as holy water. It’s imbued with positive energy the same way.
Murphy squinted at me and then at the wall. Holy? I thought magic was just all about energy and math and equations and things. Like electricity or thermodynamics.
Not everyone thinks that,
I said. I nodded at the altar. The victim was a Wiccan.
Murphy frowned. A witch?
She was also a witch,
I said. Not every Wiccan has the innate strength to be a practitioner. For most of them, there’s very little actual power involved in their rites and ceremonies.
Then why do them?
Dearly beloved, we are gathered here to join this man and this woman in holy matrimony.
I shrugged. Every faith has its ceremonies, Murph.
This was about a conflict of religion, then?
Murphy said.
I shrugged. It’s sort of difficult for sincere Wiccans to conflict with other religions. Wicca itself is really fluid. There are some basic tenets that ninety-nine percent of all Wiccans follow, but at its core the faith is all about individual freedom. Wiccans believe that as long as you aren’t hurting anyone else by doing it, you should be free to act and worship in whatever way you’d like. So everyone’s beliefs are a little bit different. Individualized.
Murphy, who was more or less Catholic, frowned. Seems to me that Christianity has a few things to say about forgiveness and tolerance and treating others the way you’d like to be treated.
Uh-huh,
I said. Then came the Crusades, the Inquisition. . . .
Which is my point,
Murphy said. Regardless of what I think about Islam or Wicca or any other religion, the fact is that it’s a group of people. Every faith has its ceremonies. And since it’s made up of people, every faith also has its assholes.
You only need one side to start a fight,
I agreed. KKK quotes a lot of scripture. So do a lot of reactionary religious organizations. A lot of times, they take it out of context.
I gestured at the wall. Like this.
I dunno. ‘Suffer not a witch to live.’ Seems fairly clear.
Out of context, but clear,
I said. Keep in mind that this appears in the same book of the Bible that approves the death sentence for a child who curses his parents, owners of oxen who injure someone through the owner’s negligence, anybody who works or kindles a fire on Sunday, and anyone who has sex with an animal.
Murphy snorted.
"Also keep in mind that the original text was written thousands of years ago. In Hebrew. The actual word that they used in that verse describes someone who casts spells that do harm to others. There was a distinction, in that culture, between harmful and beneficial magic.
"By the time we got to the Middle Ages, the general attitude within the faith was that anyone who practiced any kind of magic was automatically evil. There was no distinction between white and black magic. And when the verse came over to English, King James had a thing about witches, so ‘harmful caster of spells’ just got translated to ‘witch.’ "
Put that way, it sounds like maybe someone took it out of context,
Murphy said. But you’d get arguments from all kinds of people that the Bible has got to be perfect. That God would not permit such errors to be made in the Holy Word.
I thought God gave everyone free will,
I said. Which presumably—and evidently—includes the freedom to be incorrect when translating one language into another.
Stop making me think,
Murphy said. I’m believing over here.
I grinned. See? This is why I’m not religious. I couldn’t possibly keep my mouth shut long enough to get along with everyone else.
I thought it was because you’d never respect any religion that would have you.
That too,
I said.
Neither one of us, during this conversation, looked back toward the body in the living room. An uncomfortable silence fell. The floorboards creaked.
Murder,
Murphy said, finally, staring at the wall. Maybe someone on a holy mission.
Murder,
I said. Too soon to make any assumptions. What made you call me?
That altar,
she said. The inconsistencies about the victim.
No one is going to buy magic writing on a wall as evidence.
I know,
she said. Officially, she’s going down as a suicide.
Which means the ball is in my court,
I said.
I talked to Stallings,
she said. I’m taking a couple of days of personal leave, starting tomorrow. I’m in.
Cool.
I frowned suddenly and got a sick little feeling in my stomach. This isn’t the only suicide, is it.
Right now, I’m on the job,
Murphy said. That isn’t something I could share with you. The way someone like Butters might.
Right,
I said.
With no warning whatsoever, Murphy moved, spinning in a blur of motion that swept her leg out in a scything, ankle-height arc behind her. There was a thump of impact, and the sound of something heavy hitting the floor. Murphy—her eyes closed—sprang onto something unseen, and her hands moved in a couple of small, quick circles, fingers grasping. Then Murphy grunted, set her arms, and twisted her shoulders a little.
There was a young woman’s high-pitched gasp of pain, and abruptly, underneath Murphy, there was a girl. Murphy had her pinned on her stomach on the floor, one arm twisted behind her, wrist bent at a painful angle.
The girl was in her late teens. She wore combat boots, black fatigue pants, and a tight, cutoff grey T-shirt. She was tall, most of a foot taller than Murphy, and built like a brick house. Her hair had been cut into a short, spiky style and dyed peroxide white. A tattoo on her neck vanished under her shirt, reappeared for a bit on her bared stomach, and continued beneath the pants. She had multiple earrings, a nose ring, an eyebrow ring, and a silver stud through that spot right under her lower lip. On the hand Murphy had twisted up behind her back, she wore a bracelet of dark little glass beads.
Harry?
Murphy said in that tone of voice that, while polite and patient, demanded an explanation.
I sighed. Murph. You remember my apprentice, Molly Carpenter.
Murphy leaned to one side and looked at her profile. Oh, sure,
she said. I didn’t recognize her without the pink-and-blue hair. Also, she wasn’t invisible last time.
She gave me a look, asking if I should let her up.
I gave Murphy a wink, and squatted down on the carpet next to the girl. I gave her my best scowl. I told you to wait at the apartment and practice your focus.
"Oh, come on, Molly said.
It’s impossible. And boring as hell."
Practice makes perfect, kid.
I’ve been practicing my ass off!
Molly protested. I know fifty times as much as I did last year.
And if you keep up the pace for another six or seven years,
I said, "you might—you might—be ready to go it alone. Until then, you’re the apprentice, I’m the teacher, and you do what I tell you."
But I can help you!
Not from a jail cell,
I pointed out.
You’re trespassing on a crime scene,
Murphy told her.
Oh, please,
Molly said, both scorn and protest in her voice.
(In case it slipped by, Molly has authority issues.)
It was probably the worst thing she could have said.
Right,
Murphy said. She produced cuffs from her jacket pocket, and slapped them on Molly’s pinned wrist. You have the right to remain silent.
Molly’s eyes widened and she stared up at me. What? Harry . . .
If you choose to give up that right,
Murphy continued, chanting it with the steady pace of ritual, anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law.
I shrugged. Sorry, kid. This is real life. Look, your juvenile record is sealed, and you’ll be tried as an adult. First offense, I doubt you’ll do much more than . . . Murph?
Murphy took a break from the Miranda chant. Thirty to sixty days, maybe.
Then she resumed.
There, see? No big deal. See you in a month or three.
Molly’s face got pale. But . . . but . . .
Oh,
I added, beat someone up on the first day. Supposed to save you a lot of trouble.
Murphy dragged Molly to her feet, her hands now cuffed. Do you understand your rights as I have conveyed them to you?
Molly’s mouth fell open. She looked from Murphy to me, her expression shocked.
Or,
I said, "you might apologize."
I-I’m sorry, Harry,
she said.
I sighed. "Not to me, kid. It isn’t my crime scene."
But . . .
Molly swallowed and looked at Murphy. I was just s-standing there.
You wearing gloves?
Murphy asked.
No.
Shoes?
Yes.
Touch anything?
Um.
Molly swallowed. The door. Just pushed it a little. And that Chinese vase she’s planted her spearmint in. The one with a crack in it.
Which means,
Murphy said, that if I can show that this is a murder, a full forensic sweep could pick up your fingerprints, the imprint of your shoes, and, as brittle as your hairdo is, possibly genetic traces if any of it broke off. Since you aren’t one of the investigating officers or police consultants, that evidence would place you at the scene of the crime and could implicate you in a murder investigation.
Molly shook her head. But you just said it would be called a suic—
Even if it is, you don’t know proper procedure, the way Harry does, and your presence here might contaminate the scene and obscure evidence about the actual killer, making the murderer even more difficult to find before he strikes again.
Molly just stared at her.
That’s why there are laws about civilians and crime scenes. This isn’t a game, Miss Carpenter,
Murphy said, her voice cool, but not angry. Mistakes here could cost lives. Do you understand me?
Molly glanced from Murphy to me and back, and her shoulders sagged. I didn’t mean to . . . I’m sorry.
I said in a gentle voice, Apologies won’t give life back to the dead, Molly. You still haven’t learned to consider consequences, and you can’t afford that. Not anymore.
Molly flinched a little and nodded.
I trust that this will never happen again,
Murphy said.
No, ma’am.
Murphy looked skeptically at Molly and back to me.
She means well,
I said. She just wanted to help.
Molly gave me a grateful glance.
Murphy’s tone softened as she took the cuffs off. Don’t we all.
Molly rubbed at her wrists, wincing. Um. Sergeant? How did you know I was there?
Floorboards creaking when no one was standing on them,
I said.
Your deodorant,
Murphy said.
Your tongue stud clicked against your teeth once,
I said.
I felt some air move a few minutes ago,
Murphy said. Didn’t feel like a draft.
Molly swallowed and her face turned pink. Oh.
But we didn’t see you, did we, Murph?
Murphy shook her head. Not even a little.
A little humiliation and ego deflation, now and then, is good for apprentices. Mine sighed miserably.
Well,
I said. You’re here. Might as well tag along.
I nodded to Murphy and headed for the door.
Where are we going?
Molly asked. Both bored medtechs blinked and stared as Molly followed me out of the apartment. Murphy came out behind us and waved them in to carry the body out.
To see a friend of mine,
I said. You like polka?
Chapter
Three
I hadn’t been back to the Forensic Institute on West Harrison since that mess with Necromancers-R-Us nearly two years before. It wasn’t an unpleasant-looking place, despite the fact that it was the repository for former human beings awaiting examination. It was in a little corporate park, very clean, with green lawns and neat bushes and fresh-painted lines on the spaces in the parking lots. The buildings themselves were quietly unassuming, functional and tidy.
It was one of those places that show up a lot in my nightmares.
It wasn’t like I’d ever been a fan of viewing corpses, but a man I knew had been caught in the magical cross fire, and wound up an animated supercorpse who had nearly torn my car apart with his bare hands.
I hadn’t come back since then. I had better things to do than revisit scenes like that. But once I was there and parked and heading for the doors, it wasn’t as bad as I thought it would be, and I went in without hesitation.
This was Molly’s first visit. At my request, she had ditched much of the facial jewelry and wore an old Cubs baseball hat over her peroxide locks. Even so, she didn’t exactly cut a respectable businesslike figure, but I was content with damage control. Of course, my outfit barely qualified for business casual, and the heavy leather coat in the too-warm weather probably gave me a distinctive aura of eccentricity. Or at least it would have, if I made more money.
The guard sitting at the desk where Phil had been murdered was expecting me, but not Molly, and he told me she would have to wait. I said I’d wait, too, until Butters verified her. The guard looked sullen about being forced to expend the enormous effort it took to punch an intercom number. He growled into the phone, grunted a few times, then thumped a switch and the security door buzzed. Molly and I went on through.
There are several examination rooms at the morgue, but it’s never hard to figure out which one Butters is inside. You just listen for the polka.
I homed in on a steady oom-pah, oom-pah of a tuba, until I could pick up the strains of clarinet and accordion skirling along with it. Exam room three. I rapped briefly on the door and opened it without actually stepping inside.
Waldo Butters was bent over his desk, squinting at his computer’s screen, while his butt and legs shuffled back and forth in time to the polka music. He muttered something to himself, nodded, and hit the space bar on his keyboard with one elbow in time with his tapping heels, without looking up at me. Hey, Harry.
I blinked. Is that ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’?
Yankovic. Man’s a freaking genius,
he replied. Give me a sec to power down before you come all the way in.
No problem,
I told him.
You’ve worked with him before?
Molly asked quietly.
Uh-huh,
I said. He’s clued.
Butters waited until his printer started rattling, then shut down the computer and walked to the printer to pick up a couple of pages and staple them together. Then he dropped the pages onto a small stack of them and bound them with a large rubber band. Okay, that should do it.
He turned to face me with a grin.
Butters was an odd little duck. He wasn’t much taller than Murphy, and she probably had more muscle than he did. His shock of black hair resembled nothing so much as an explosion in a steel wool factory. He was all knees and elbows, especially in the surgical greens he was wearing, his face was lean and angular, his nose beaky, and his eyes were bright behind the prescription glasses.
Harry,
he said, offering his hand. Long time, no see. How’s the hand?
I traded grips with him. Butters had long, wiry fingers, very precise and not at all weak. He wasn’t anyone’s idea of dangerous, but the little guy had guts and brains. Only three months or so. And not too bad.
I held my gloved left hand up and wiggled all the fingers. My ring and pinkie fingers moved with little trembles and twitches, but by God they moved when I told them to.
The flesh of my left hand had practically melted in an unanticipated conflagration during a battle with a scourge of vampires. The doctors had been shocked that they didn’t have to amputate, but told me I’d never use it again. Butters had helped me work out a regimen of physical therapy, and my fingers were mostly functional, though my hand still looked pretty horrible—but even that had begun to change, at least a little. The ugly little lumps of scar tissue and flesh had begun to fade, and my hand looked considerably less like a melted wax model than it had before. The nails had grown back in, too.
Good,
Butters said. Good. You still playing guitar?
I hold it. It makes noise. Might be a little generous to call it playing.
I gestured to Molly. Waldo Butters, this is Molly Carpenter, my apprentice.
Apprentice, eh?
Butters extended an amiable hand. Pleased to meetcha,
he said. "So does he turn you into squirrels and fishes and stuff, like in The Sword in the Stone?"
Molly sighed. I wish. I keep trying to get him to show me how to change form, but he won’t.
I promised your parents I wouldn’t let you melt yourself into a pile of goo,
I told her. Butters, I assume someone—and I won’t name any names—told you I’d be dropping by?
Yowsa,
the little ME said, nodding. He held up a finger, went to the door, and locked it, before turning to lean his back against it. Look, Dresden. I have to be careful what kind of information I share, right? It comes with the job.
Sure.
So you didn’t hear it from me.
I looked at Molly. Who said that?
Groovy,
Butters said. He walked back over to me and offered me the packet of papers. Names and addresses of the deceased,
he said.
I frowned and flipped through them: columns of text, much of it technical; ugly photographs. The victims?
Officially, they’re the deceased.
His mouth tightened. But yeah. I’m pretty sure they’re victims.
Why?
He opened his mouth, closed it again, and frowned. You ever see something out of the corner of your eye? But when you look at it, there’s nothing there? Or at least, it doesn’t look like what you thought it was?
Sure.
Same thing here,
he said. Most of these folks show classic, obvious suicides. There are just a few little details wrong. You know?
No,
I said. Enlighten me.
Take that top one,
he said. Pauline Moskowitz. Thirty-nine, mother of two, husband, two dogs. She disappears on a Friday night and opens up her wrists in a hotel bathtub around three A.M. Saturday morning.
I read over it. Am I reading this right? She was on antidepressants?
Uh-huh,
Butters said, but nothing extreme, and she’d been on them and stable for eight years. Never showed suicidal tendencies before, either.
I looked at the ugly picture of a very ordinary-looking woman lying naked and dead in a tub of cloudy liquid. So what’s got your scalpel in a knot?
The cuts,
Butters said. She used a box knife. It was in the tub with her. She severed tendons in both wrists.
So?
So,
Butters said. Once she’d cut the tendons on one wrist, she’d have had very little controlled movement with the fingers in that hand. So what’d she do to cut them both? Use two box knives at the same time? Where’s the other knife?
Maybe she held it with her teeth,
I said.
Maybe I’ll close my eyes and throw a rock out over the lake and it will land in a boat,
Butters said. It’s technically possible, but it isn’t really likely. The second wound almost certainly wouldn’t be as deep or as clean. I’ve seen ’em look like someone was cutting up a block of Parmesan into slivers. These two cuts are almost identical.
I guess it’s not conclusive, though,
I said.
Not officially.
I’ve been hearing that a lot today.
I frowned. What’s Brioche think?
At the mention of his boss, Butters grimaced. Occam’s razor, to use his own spectacularly insensitive yet ironic phrasing. They’re suicides. End of story.
But your guess is that someone else was holding the knife?
The little ME’s face turned bleak, and he nodded without speaking.
Good enough for me,
I said. What about the body today?
Can’t say until I look,
Butters said. He gave me a shrewd glance. But you think it’s another murder.
I know it is,
I replied. But I’m the only one, until Murphy’s off the clock.
Right.
Butters sighed.
I flipped past Mrs. Moskowitz’s pages to the next set of ugly pictures. Also a woman. The pages named her Maria Casselli. Maria had been twenty-three when she washed down thirty Valium with a bottle of drain cleaner.
Another hotel room,
I noted quietly.
Molly glanced over my shoulder at the printout of the photo at the scene. She turned pale and took several steps away from me.
Yeah,
Butters said, concerned eyes on my apprentice. It’s a little unusual. Most suicides are at home. They usually go somewhere else only if they need to jump off a bridge or drive their car into a lake or something.
Ms. Casselli had a family,
I said. Husband, her younger sister living with her.
Yeah,
Butters said. You can guess what Brioche had to say.
She walked in on her hubby and baby sister, decided to end it all?
Uh-huh.
Uh,
Molly said. I think—
Outside,
Butters provided, unlocking the door. First door on the right.
Molly hurried from the room, down to the bathroom Butters had directed her to.
Jesus, Harry,
Butters said. Kid’s a little young for this.
I held up the picture of Maria’s body. Lot of that going around.
She’s actually a wizard? Like you?
Someday,
I said. If she survives.
I read over the next two profiles, both of women in their twenties, both apparent suicides in hotel rooms, both of them with housemates of one sort or another.
The last profile was different. I read over it and glanced up at Butters. What’s with this one?
Fits the same general profile,
Butters said. Women, dead in hotel rooms.
I frowned down at the papers. Where’s the cause of death?
That’s the thing,
Butters said. I couldn’t find one.
I lifted both eyebrows at him.
He spread his hands. Harry, I know my trade. I like figuring this stuff out. And I haven’t got the foggiest why the woman is dead. Every test I ran came up negative; every theory I put together fell apart. Medically speaking, she’s in good shape. It’s like her whole system just . . . got the switch turned off. Everything at once. Never seen anything like it.
Jessica Blanche.
I checked the profiles. Nineteen. And pretty. Or at least prettyish.
Hard to tell with dead girls,
Butters said. But yeah, that was my take.
But not a suicide.
Like I said. Dead, and in hotel rooms.
Then what’s the connection to the other deaths?
Little things,
Butters said. Like, she had a purse with ID in it, but no clothes.
Meaning someone had to have taken them away.
I rolled up the papers into a tube and thumped them against my leg, thoughtfully. The door opened, and Molly came back in, wiping at her mouth with a paper towel. This girl still here?
Butters lifted his eyebrows. Yeah. Miss Blanche. Why?
I think maybe Molly can help.
Molly blinked and looked up at me. Um. What?
I doubt it’s going to be pleasant, Molly,
I told her. But you might be able to read something.
Off of a dead girl?
Molly asked quietly.
You’re the one who wanted to come along,
I said.
She frowned, facing me, and then took a deep breath. Yes. Um. Yes, I was. I mean, yes, I will. Try.
Will you?
I asked. You sure? Won’t be fun. But if it gets us more information, it could save someone’s life.
I watched her for a moment, until her expression set in determination and she met my eyes. She straightened and nodded once. Yes.
All right,
I said. Get yourself set for it. Butters, we need to give her a few minutes alone. Can we go get Miss Blanche?
Um,
Butters said. What’s this going to entail, exactly?
Nothing much. I’ll explain it on the way.
He chewed on his lip for a moment, and then nodded once. This way.
He led me down the hall to the storage room. It was another exam room, like the one we’d just been in, but it also featured a wall of body-sized refrigerated storage units like morgues are supposed to have. This was the room we’d been in when a necromancer and a gaggle of zombies had put a bullet through the head of Butters’s capacity to ignore the world of the supernatural.
Butters got out a gurney, consulted a record sheet on a clipboard, and wheeled it over to the fridges. I don’t like to come in here anymore. Not since Phil.
Me either,
I said.
He nodded. Here, get that side.
I didn’t want to. I am a wizard, sure, but corpses are inherently icky, even if they aren’t animated and trying to kill you. But I tried to pretend we were sliding a heavy load of groceries onto a cart, and helped him draw a body, resting upon a metal tray and covered in a heavy cloth, onto the gurney.
So,
he said. What is she going to do?
Look into its eyes,
I said.
He gave me a somewhat skeptical look. Trying to see the last thing impressed on her retinas or something? You know that’s pretty much mythical, right?
Other impressions get left on a body,
I said. Final thoughts, sometimes. Emotions, sensations.
I shook my head. Technically, those kinds of impressions can get left on almost any kind of inanimate object. You’ve heard of object reading, right?
That’s for real?
he asked.
Yeah. But it’s an easy sort of thing to contaminate, and it can be tricky as hell—and entirely apart from that, it’s extremely difficult to do.
Oh,
Butters said. But you think there might be something left on the corpse?
Maybe.
That sounds really useful.
Potentially.
So how come you don’t do it all the time?
he asked.
It’s delicate,
I said. When it comes to magic, I’m not much for delicate.
He frowned and we started rolling the gurney. But your only half-trained apprentice is?
The wizarding business isn’t standardized,
I said. Any given wizard will have an affinity for different kinds of magic, due to their natural talents, personalities, experiences. Each has different strengths.
What are yours?
he asked.
Finding things. Following things. Blowing things up, mostly,
I said. "I’m good at those. Redirecting energy, sending energy out
