The Major Philosophical Reflections in St. Augustine's Confessions

By Robert Scott

The narrative in Confessions oscillates between Augustine's personal experience and his philosophical reflection, and in doing so, it provides profound insights into the nature of human existence. The centrality of memory and time in the text is particularly significant. In Book XI, Augustine meditates on the nature of time in a way that has influenced subsequent thinkers for centuries. His reflections on the past, present, and future, and the inability of humans to grasp the present fully because it is constantly slipping away into the past, echo themes from ancient philosophy, particularly the work of Plato and Aristotle. Augustine, however, introduces a theological twist, positing that time is a created reality, and only God exists outside of time, eternal and unchanging.

Augustine's profound insights into the human will and its struggle between sin and grace would later lay the foundations for Christian doctrines of original sin and salvation. His ideas were revolutionary in the sense that they placed the human will at the center of the moral universe. Before Augustine, much of the philosophical and theological discussion had been focused on the metaphysical nature of God or the cosmos. Augustine, however, turned inward, scrutinizing the human soul's desires, motives, and capacity for evil. He famously remarked in Confessions that his turning away from God in his youth was not due to external circumstances, but rather his own disordered will: "You have made us for Yourself, O Lord, and our heart is restless until it rests in You."

• Language: English
• Publisher: Historia Magna
• Release date: Feb 18, 2025
• ISBN: 9798230095910

Book preview

Chapter 1: Introduction to St. Augustine's Life and Work

St. Augustine of Hippo, born in 354 CE in Thagaste (modern-day Souk Ahras, Algeria), stands as one of the most influential philosophers and theologians in Western intellectual history. His life spanned an era of profound transformation for the Roman Empire. The period in which Augustine was born witnessed the decline of the Roman Empire and the rise of Christianity from a persecuted sect to the official religion of the Empire by the time of his death in 430 CE. Augustine's work bridged the classical world of Greco-Roman thought with the emerging Christian theological tradition, profoundly shaping both medieval and modern philosophy.

Augustine’s Confessions, written between 397 and 400 CE, is both an autobiographical account and a philosophical treatise. In it, Augustine narrates his spiritual journey from a life of indulgence in sin to his eventual conversion to Christianity. At its core, Confessions is an exploration of the inner workings of the human soul, its struggle with sin, the nature of God, and the quest for ultimate truth. But it also serves as a reflection on the nature of memory, time, self-identity, free will, and grace, all of which became central themes in Augustine’s later works.

Born to a Christian mother, Monica, and a pagan father, Patricius, Augustine's early life was marked by spiritual ambivalence. His father was not an influential figure in his intellectual development, but his mother played a crucial role in his eventual conversion. However, during his youth, Augustine followed a path that led him through various philosophical and religious systems, including Manichaeism, a dualistic faith founded by the Persian prophet Mani. Augustine was deeply engaged with Manichaeism, which posited a cosmic struggle between the forces of good (light) and evil (darkness), and for a time, he believed it offered an intellectually coherent explanation of the world. The experience left an indelible mark on his thinking, especially his subsequent reflections on the nature of evil.

However, it was his encounter with Neoplatonism that proved transformative. The teachings of Plotinus, which he encountered through the writings of his teacher Ambrose, the Bishop of Milan, offered a more sophisticated framework that Augustine could reconcile with his growing Christian faith. Neoplatonism, with its emphasis on the soul’s ascent towards the One (or Good), and the understanding that evil is not a substance but a corruption of the good, provided Augustine with the intellectual resources to rethink his view of God, creation, and the problem of evil. It was here that Augustine’s philosophy began to turn towards the Christian conception of a benevolent, omnipotent God who allowed free will to exist within a creation that was ultimately good.

The narrative in Confessions oscillates between Augustine's personal experience and his philosophical reflection, and in doing so, it provides profound insights into the nature of human existence. The centrality of memory and time in the text is particularly significant. In Book XI, Augustine meditates on the nature of time in a way that has influenced subsequent thinkers for centuries. His reflections on the past, present, and future, and the inability of humans to grasp the present fully because it is constantly slipping away into the past, echo themes from ancient philosophy, particularly the work of Plato and Aristotle. Augustine, however, introduces a theological twist, positing that time is a created reality, and only God exists outside of time, eternal and unchanging.

Augustine’s profound insights into the human will and its struggle between sin and grace would later lay the foundations for Christian doctrines of original sin and salvation. His ideas were revolutionary in the sense that they placed the human will at the center of the moral universe. Before Augustine, much of the philosophical and theological discussion had been focused on the metaphysical nature of God or the cosmos. Augustine, however, turned inward, scrutinizing the human soul’s desires, motives, and capacity for evil. He famously remarked in Confessions that his turning away from God in his youth was not due to external circumstances, but rather his own disordered will: You have made us for Yourself, O Lord, and our heart is restless until it rests in You.

The role of grace in Augustine’s theology cannot be overstated. His later works, particularly The City of God, would elaborate on grace as the means by which humans are redeemed from sin, a stark contrast to his earlier views where he believed in the ability of human beings to achieve salvation through their own efforts. The doctrine of grace, as developed by Augustine, would later become a cornerstone of Western Christian thought, especially in relation to the theological debates between Augustine’s followers and the Pelagians, who believed that humans could achieve moral perfection on their own.

Confessions also represents a profound shift in the relationship between the individual and God. For much of classical antiquity, the primary concern of philosophy was the nature of the cosmos and the human’s place within it. While personal introspection was certainly not absent from philosophers like Socrates or Plato, the spiritual journey in Confessions is unique in its intensely personal, relational focus between the human soul and God. This is a new direction in Western thought, one that would become central to later Christian mysticism and existential philosophy.

The intellectual context of Augustine’s Confessions must also be understood in relation to the works of other ancient philosophers. The Platonists, especially the Neoplatonists, greatly influenced his metaphysical ideas, while the Stoics, particularly in their ethical theories, played a role in shaping his views on self-discipline and the proper life. Aristotle’s influence is less direct, but his philosophy of ethics and logic would permeate Augustine’s thinking as he synthesized classical ideas with Christian teachings.

The Confessions is not merely a theological treatise, but a work that explores the perennial questions of philosophy: What is the nature of truth? What is the good life? What does it mean to be human? How do we reconcile free will with divine omnipotence? Augustine’s work addresses these questions with a depth and a passion that makes it a foundational text not just for Christian philosophy but for the history of Western thought as a whole. His examination of the self, the soul, and its relationship with God marks a crucial turning point in the intellectual history of the Western world, bridging ancient philosophy with the religious, philosophical, and political upheavals of the Middle Ages.

The philosophical reflections found in Confessions were not isolated to Augustine’s time but reverberated through the centuries. The influence of Confessions and Augustine’s broader corpus of work shaped the development of medieval philosophy, particularly in the work of scholars such as Anselm of Canterbury, Thomas Aquinas, and Martin Luther. His exploration of grace, sin, and salvation would lay the groundwork for Christian doctrines that would persist through the Reformation, the Enlightenment, and into modern theological debates.

The legacy of St. Augustine's philosophical insights in Confessions continues to shape the study of philosophy, theology, and the humanities today. Through his deep introspection, his powerful prose, and his philosophical depth, Augustine’s Confessions remains a vital and profound contribution to understanding the human condition and the divine. It is both a personal narrative and a work of philosophical genius, the reflections of a man who wrestled with questions of ultimate importance to both the self and the universe.

Chapter 2: The Nature of Time and Memory

One of the most profound and influential philosophical themes that emerges in St. Augustine’s Confessions is his examination of the nature of time and memory. This theme not only encapsulates the internal struggles of the human soul but also serves as a cornerstone of Augustine's broader metaphysical and theological reflections. Augustine’s insights into the passage of time are not merely intellectual abstractions but are intimately tied to his Christian faith, particularly his understanding of God’s eternity and the created world’s temporality. In examining these reflections, it is essential to understand the intellectual and historical context in which Augustine wrote, as well as the deep connections he draws between human experience, memory, and divine revelation.

The nature of time is a question that stretches back to ancient philosophy. Greek philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle had their own conceptions of time, though these notions were deeply rooted in their understanding of the cosmos. Plato, in his Timaeus, for example, associated time with the movement of the heavens, viewing it as a divine ordering principle that reflected the eternal forms. Aristotle, in his Physics, offered a more practical understanding of time, defining it as the measurement of change with respect to before and after. Time, for Aristotle, was not an independent entity but was intricately tied to motion and change in the material world. However, neither of these philosophers developed a view of time that was as deeply personal and theological as Augustine’s.

Augustine’s reflections on time, particularly in Confessions Book XI,